| Earned Value Analysis
What is EVA?
EVA is simply net operating profits after tax, minus a charge
for the use of capital employed in the business. The capital
charge is the minimum rate of return necessary to compensate
shareholders, and lenders for the risk of their investments
in a company. Research shows that changes in EVA has a closer
correlation to changes in shareholder value, when compared
to other metrics like Earnings Per Share (EPS), Earnings Growth,
Return on Equity (ROE), and Return on Assets (ROA).
To improve EVA
- Invest in projects that earn more than the cost of capital
will help in achieving growth to improve EVA
- Increase profits without using additional capital will
help in increasing EVA through productivity improvement.
- Divesting non-strategic assets that do not generate operating
profits greater than the cost of capital.
Steps increase EVA
By focusing on EVA, employees throughout an organisation
have to make strategic and operating decisions that would
increase EVA and in turn, shareholder value. Consider a company
ABC Ltd. The significant actions the company has taken in
the last 2-3 years include the following:
- Sale of its Metal Services company
- Acquisition of the Kerr brand of home canning products
- Improved operating efficiencies at Plastic Packaging
Operating profits in the Metal services unit had been well
below the cost of capital. Long-term prospects in this industry
did not show signs of a turnaround. On the other hand, the
acquisition and integration of the brand of home canning products
provided an opportunity to increase EVA significantly. Improved
operating efficiency, combined with reduction in capital employed
in Plastic packaging operation in the last two years has contributed
to ABCs recent EVA improvement.
EVA- related incentive compensation
To assure that the managements interest is in line
with that of ABCs shareholders, the managements
incentive compensation is tied to EVA. ABCs incentive
compensation plan is based on a specific formula. Annual EVA
targets are established for each operation based upon the
previous years actual performance. This target setting
approach rewards managers for continuous EVA improvement.
It is also consistent with ABCs long-term value creation
strategy.
The Importance of EVA and its Indian Implication
This concept has been picking up in India. Some companies
have already made EVA a part of their annual reports-- Infosys
Technologies, Hindustan Lever Limited and Dr. Reddy laboratories,
to name a few. The reasons for EVA being adopted by only a
few companies in India are: -
- There is more than one set of shareholders for Indian
companies and the company cannot satisfy one set without
displeasing other
- Lack of transparency and consistency in reporting
Calculation of EVA
For calculation of EVA the following elements are needed
as inputs: -
Beta (b)
Market Return (Rm)
Risk free rate of return (Rf)
Cost of equity (Ke)
Cost of Debt (Kd)
Weighted average cost of capital (WACC)
Total borrowings
Weightage of debt in total capital employed (Wd)
Weightage of networth in total capital employed (We)
Capital employed = debt + networth (equity + reserve and
surplus)
Operating profit before interest and tax (OPBIT)
EXAMPLE
Say,
ß = 0.90
Rm = 19 % = 0.19
Rf = 11 % = 0.11
Using CAPM we can get cost of equity (Ke) = (Rf + b(Rm
Rf))
Ke = 0.11+0. 9 (0.19 - 0.11) = 0.18
Ke = 18 % = 0.18
Kd = 3 % = 0.03
Wd = 11 % =0. 11
We = 89% = 0.89
Now WACC = Ke * We + Kd * Wd
= 0.18 * 0.89 + 0.03 * 0.11
= 16 % = 0.16
Capital employed = 2165 crores.
Tax = 225 crores.
Now, calculation of EVA
Crores
Sales = 1000
Less: crores
Manufacturing cost = 200
Operating cost = 100
Depreciation = 4
304
OPBIT = 696
Less:
Tax = 225
471
WACC (2165 Cr. * .16)= 346
EVA =125
|